Halo vs SpotOn: what each costs over two years, and whether you need a plan.
Verdict on price: at today's prices Halo is cheaper for the first 43 months ($659 vs $849 at month 24), because SpotOn costs more up front but needs no plan. Pick Halo's Gold plan and it passes SpotOn in month 22. Our drift tests haven't run yet, so this verdict is about cost only.
Cost over 24 months, collar plus plan
Cheapest plan that keeps each fence working. Prices checked Nov 22, 2026.
- Halo Collar 5: $419 + Bronze plan
- SpotOn Nova: $849 + no plan
- Guardian GPS 2.0: $360 + Annual plan
How we'll test drift
The fence line and the loop we'll walk 10 times per collar. Each collar's GPS trace goes on this plan after its walk.
- Fence we set
- Route we walk
- Collar traces appear here after the first walk
Every collar on file
The same table on every page. Drift fills in after each collar is walked in our yard; until then, it says so.
| Collar | Price | Plan to keep the fence working | 24-month cost | Correction | Battery (maker) | Drift in our yard | More |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Halo Collar 5Dogs 10 lb and up, necks 8 to 30 in | $419list $599, Nov 22, 2026 | Bronze, $9.99/mo | $659 | Sound, vibration or static, in warning, boundary and emergency stagesStatic is optional | Up to 48 hours | Not tested yet | More |
| SpotOn GPS Fence, Nova EditionDogs 15 lb and up, necks 10 to 26 in | $849list $999, Nov 22, 2026 | None required | $849 | Two warning tones, then vibration, then optional static (30 levels)Static is optional | At least 33 hours with tracking on | Not tested yet | More |
| PetSafe Guardian GPS 2.0Dogs 10 lb and up, necks 8 in and up | $359.99Nov 22, 2026 | Annual, $8.25/mo ($99/yr) | $558 | Tone, vibration or 10 levels of static | Up to 70 hours | Not tested yet | More |
Prices are the makers' own, including holiday sales with no end date shown. Fences that need no plan at all
True cost calculator
Pick a collar, a plan and how long you'll keep it. Prices checked Nov 22, 2026.
Collar price plus plan charges. Prepaid plans are charged per term up front. Tax, shipping and add-ons not included.
Does the Halo collar shock?
Only if you choose static. Halo offers sound, vibration and static, and says you're never required to use static. Full answer
A GPS fence without a subscription?
SpotOn's fence works with no plan; tracking costs extra. Cheaper no-plan collars exist, but most we found draw a circle, not your yard's shape. See the list
Halo deals this week
Halo lists the Collar 5 at $419, down from $599. We don't post promo codes we haven't tried at checkout. Current prices